AI Movie Evaluation Criteria 

​

For AI movie, the primary challenge is overcoming "hallucinations" while maintaining visual stability and narrative depth. Here are some of the elements we take into account:

​

1. Temporal Consistency: Do the characters and environments remain the same from frame to frame, or do faces and clothing glitch?

2. Motion Fidelity: Does the movement look natural or "rubbery"? Special focus is given to human gait and the physics of elements like water or fire.

3. Prompt Adherence: How accurately does the video follow the script? High scores go to works that depict complex actions without anatomical errors.

4. Screenwriting & Narrative Cohesion: Is there a compelling story with a clear structure and emotional depth? We prioritize works where AI tools enhance the plot and pacing, proving the movie is driven by human intent rather than random generation.

5. Innovation: Does the creator push the boundaries of current tools? We value the clever use of custom models, LoRAs, or hybrid workflows (e.g., blending 3D with AI) to achieve unique results.

6. Surreal Factor (Creativity): bonus points for innovative aesthetics that would be impossible or too expensive to film with a camera.

7. Editing & Sound Design: An AI movie isn't just a generated clip; it should be a complete work with a cohesive soundscape and effects.

​​

​

 AI Song Evaluation Criteria 

​

In music, the key is distinguishing generic "noise" from true composition. Here are some of the elements we take into account:

​

1. Vocal Emotion (Vocal Realism): Does the voice sound robotic, or does it have natural breaths, vibrato, and emotion that match the lyrics?

2. Structural Cohesion: Does the song have a clear structure (intro, chorus, bridge), or does it repeat randomly?

3. Lyric Depth: Assessing whether the lyrics are generic "AI style" full of clichés or offer fresh metaphors and meaningful storytelling.

4. Production Clarity: Is the audio crisp, or are there digital artifacts (hissing) common in lower-end AI models?

5. Genre Originality: How well the AI blends contrasting styles (e.g., "Cyberpunk Folk").

6. Dynamic Range and Narrative Flow: Does the track evolve over time—building and releasing tension—or does it maintain a flat, constant intensity from start to finish?

7. Artistic Intent (The "Soul" Factor): Beyond technical perfection, does the piece convey a deliberate message or unique creative vision? This distinguishes a calculated assembly of sounds from a cohesive artistic work that resonates on a human level.

​​

​

Once editors verify that a movie or song meets the required criteria, it could be inducted into the official TOPsurreal chart as a New Entry.

 

Entries and rankings are determined by a precise formula that integrates views, likes, social media comments, alongside other key engagement metrics.

 

The chart is updated periodically to reflect new entries and current trends.